After 55 days, the station became concerned that the contest would never end.
"We sensed these two were not going to back down," said John Flint, a co-host on the station's morning show. "There was no way we expected this to go 55 days. If it was not for the deal, it's possible they could have gone on until New Year's."
On Tuesday, the station offered the two a compromise: End the contest and receive $10,000 toward the purchase of a car, among other prizes, or continue with the runner-up receiving nothing.
Within 15 minutes, both agreed to the deal.
"Both of us were ready to go home," Kempfer said, "but we didn't want to leave with nothing after you put in that much time."
Thompson called the contest a "very good experience" but said she wouldn't do it again.
Information from: Wisconsin State Journal, http://www.madison.com/wsj