Blogs ·  Liveblogs ·  Capture Kansas ·  Widgets ·  13 On Your Cell ·  Desktop Alert ·  In the Community ·  My Rewards
Home  ·   Local  ·   U.S. & World  ·   Weather  ·   Sports  ·   Political  ·   Money/Stocks  ·   Blogs  ·   Meet the Team  ·   Jobs  ·  
Mr. Food Recipes · KS Prep Zone · Shopping Plaza · Classifieds · Coupons · Programming · 13 On Your Cell
Sound Off about EuthanasiaWIBW Blog Listing
Sound Off about Euthanasia
Topic Author: Stephanie Ramos
Posted: 10:37 AM Mar 20, 2008
Replies Posted: 5 comments
Save Email Print
 del.icio.us   Google   Yahoo  digg
Recent Blog Topics
Greetings, everyone!
Come Celebrate with Mana de Topeka!
I'm A Cop!
Back to School
Ramobama '08
UNITY 2008
Post Your Comments
First Name:
Email (optional):
Location:
Enter Comments:  
   characters left
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.

Sound Off about Euthanasia

Euthanasia usually sparks alot of controversy. One woman in France sparked more than that when she requested assistance for her suicide.  When a disease gets so difficult...and is slowly killing you what do you do?  ~SR

The below article is courtesy of CNN

PARIS, France -- A French woman severely disfigured by facial tumors has been been found dead just two days after a court rejected her request for an assisted suicide.

Sebire had suffered from a rare and incurable form of cancer for eight years.

Medical examiners were Thursday looking into the death of 52-year-old Chantal Sebire -- whose case had prompted nominally Roman Catholic France to reexamine its stance on euthanasia -- to determine whether anything illegal had taken place.

It was not immediately clear how Sebire died.

Sebire had suffered from esthesioneuroblastoma, a rare and incurable form of cancer for eight years, developing tumors in her nasal passages and sinuses that distorted her face and caused her nose and eyes to bulge.

The woman from Dijon, in eastern France, said drugs were ineffective against the excruciating pain caused by the condition and there was no reason doctors should not be permitted to hasten her death.

Assisted suicide is illegal in France, however. The law permits only passive euthanasia -- removing feeding and hydration tubes when a person is in a coma, or inducing a coma and then removing the tubes.

Sebire's lawyer had tried to convince a French court that it was "barbaric" to put her through the ordeal of dying slowly in an artificial coma, something that could take up to two weeks while her three children looked on in anguish.

The court turned down the appeal Monday.

At the same time, Sebire wrote a letter to French President Nicolas Sarkozy appealing for help, but he responded by suggesting top doctors should reexamine her for a second opinion.

Her plight and the questions it raised caused so much public debate in France that when Sebire was found dead Wednesday night, it made front-page news in heavyweight papers including Le Figaro and Le Parisien.

CNN Senior International Correspondent Jim Bitterman in Paris said the Sebire had many supporters in France with hundreds of people writing to her to express their backing.

"One of the reasons for this is this woman was a relatively young mother of three children and many people could sympathize. People think 'what would I do in the same circumstances.'"

A French group called the Association for the Right to Die with Dignity, which took up Sebire's cause, believes laws must be changed to take such cases into account.

"It is not the liberty of a politician or a doctor -- it's the liberty of the person who is suffering, who has a terminal disease," said Jean-Luc Romero, president of the group.

"It's only the decision of the people who have a terminal disease to decide (whether they may die)."

Others disagree. "It isn't because a citizen says 'I want this' that we should modify the law," said Patrick Verspieren, a Jesuit bio-ethics expert. "The law is already quite open."

France's prime minister, health and justice ministers all made clear they did not believe changes in French law are needed.

Read Comments
Posted by: rb there is a certain dignity to life.I support euthanasia only for the most dire of situations.

Posted by: Mary Location: Topeka
Suicide to escape the pains of this life is not an acceptable option for the Christian. The 5th Commandment says: Thou shalt not kill. And that includes ourselves. The Lord Jesus told us that if we intend to follow Him we must deny ourselves (an easy out)and take up our daily cross (Lk 9:23). He left us the example of His own life, passion and ignominious death on the cross. He does not ask His followers to do any more than He did Himself. Catholics know that sufferings do not have to be borne in vain. We will either do our purgatory here on earth or in eternity. Therefore sufferings borne with resignation can shorten our time in Purgatory after death. Our sufferings united to those of Christ can also obtain the conversion of sinners. (Refer to the messages of Our Lady of Fatima who said that many sinners go to Hell because they have no one to pray for them and make sacrifices for them.) Most saints have also given us the example of bearing great sufferings--even martyrdom.

Posted by: Suzy I agree with Jan. It's obvious she was suffering. Why not allow terminally ill patients decide when and how to go? Let them die with their dignity intact.

STEPHANIE: I totally understand...it's so controversial because there are soo many sides. It's not a yes and no answer. Thank you for your comment.


Posted by: PS It was her choice, the state should never have been involved. None of can say what we would do, because we arent in her shoes. So sad, such a sad way to die. She should have been given the dignity to choose her path.

Posted by: Jan Location: Manhattan
I believe when there is no hope that the person should be able to decide their fate. This poor woman was in a lot of pain, could not see, could not taste, could not breathe properly would you want to live that way. I think I would not. If this was one our cats or dogs it would be called cruelty what about cruelty to this lady.

STEPHANIE: It is very sad. Thank you for your comment.