Blogs ·  Liveblogs ·  Capture Kansas ·  Widgets ·  13 On Your Cell ·  Desktop Alert ·  In the Community ·  My Rewards
Home  ·   Local  ·   U.S. & World  ·   Weather  ·   Sports  ·   Political  ·   Money/Stocks  ·   Blogs  ·   Meet the Team  ·   Jobs  ·  
Mr. Food Recipes · KS Prep Zone · Shopping Plaza · Classifieds · Coupons · Programming · 13 On Your Cell
WIBW

$$$$$$$$
Blogs



Weather
Sports
Web Features
On-Air Programs
Man Gets Probation for Raping 14-Year-Old Save Email Print
Reporter: Brian Quick
Email Address: brian.quick@wibw.com

A | A | A

A mother and father are speaking out tonight about the sentence handed down for the man convicted of sexually assaulting their 14-year old daughter-- not prison.. but probation.

Orlando Paul Cisneros was convicted on 17 counts.

Today -- a judge suspended the recommended sentence of nearly 13 years in prison... and instead, put him on three years probation.

The Burlison family felt that justice was not done in this case, and that Cisneros should see prison time.

They also feel another case sheds some light -- and concern -- on the judge who made the decision.

Michael Burlison made an emotional statement in court today on behalf of his daughter.

Little did he know, the man convicted of raping her would see no prison time.

The sentence comes from Judge Matthew Dowd -- just yesterday, he made a similar decision in the case of Federico Mendoza -- suspending a 12-year prison sentence for soliciting sex from who he thought was a young girl online... placing him on three years probation also.

Cisneros' attorney Cindy Sewell said in a statement that judge Dowd was the only person who saw, heard and evaluated all of the evidence in the case.

The family doesn't accept that.

Meanwhile, the victim is emotional over the whole situation.

The family says they'll appeal the case -- but believe any change in the sentence is unlikely.

We left a message for Judge Dowd -- he did not return the call.

More Stories
Car Show Gears Up Supporters for a Good Cause

Deputies Scare Off Suspects Mid-Burglary

Topeka Police Officers--- To be

Kansas Test Scores Top National Average

Police Ask for Help Locating Man in Connection with Assault

Obama Accepts Nomination, Links McCain and Bush

Topeka Democrats React To Obama Nomination

Child Run Over After Knocking Vehicle into Neutral

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: alicia Location: concordia on Aug 25, 2008 at 05:13 PM
Hmm dont know what to say... I myself 2 daughters and cant stand another sex offender out in the world...what in the heck is going on in the world 3 years in prison isnt enough let alone 3 years of probation...I myself am going through it to my oldest daughter was raped and shes 4 We will find out what a small town judge will do

Posted by: jolynn Location: hutchinson on Jun 26, 2007 at 09:49 AM
I have lost alot of confidence in the justice system,this girl will live with this forever and the jerk who did this will probably forget, probably already has. This judge needs to think about the victim and not the a--h--- who did this to her. My heart goes out to the family-my family-and all my love.I just hope that she gets to have a semi-normal life in the future, and I hope he doesn't-karma!!

Posted by: robert Location: kenner, ls on Jun 20, 2007 at 11:33 PM
Sad, Sad, Sad, to see someone such as judge Dowd in that position of resposibility being irresposible at the expense of our children. What is in your brain judge Down and your heart? Are you crazy? Most of us who care about children are angry at your behavior and believe you have thrown justice into the sewers.You have redefined wrong and evil into right and moral.That will happen only in your mind not in the real world. Shame on you.

Posted by: Outraged Location: Topeka on Jun 20, 2007 at 12:24 AM
I saw Michael Burlison on the O'Reilly Factor last night. He looked very, very sad, almost like he was going to burst into tears at any moment. Nevertheless, he got through the interview with dignity and was very articulate. I can't imagine how emotional I would be if it was one of my daughters. What Judge Dowd did goes beyond any sensibilty, and was in fact a crime against my daughters and all children in his jurisdiction who are not resting safer because of him. Shawnee County should use its power to remove Dowd from all future criminal cases until he either retires or we can vote this lame excuse for a judge out of office.

Posted by: John Location: Bethlehem, PA on Jun 18, 2007 at 07:55 PM
Judge Dowd's actions are reprehensible. A concertwd effort should be made to remove this man from the bench--he is a danger to society.

Posted by: Jose Location: C alifornia on Jun 18, 2007 at 07:38 PM
This judge is a disgrace, I hope he rots in hell!

Posted by: steve Location: salina,ks. on Jun 16, 2007 at 06:37 AM
As no one kows the whole story with this 14 yr. old I have to support our justice system.. Some states 14 is of leagal age as I found out with ny daughter in Maryland when I caught her with a 37 yr old man..However if this was forceable and against her will, which I doubt with 17 counts I wouldn"t feel this way..

Posted by: Chris Location: PA on Jun 14, 2007 at 10:29 AM
That sentence is an outrage. A conviction on a rape charge should be a deterrent to doing it again and 3 years probation for screwing up a victim's life, sense of safety, and mental health isn't even a slap on the fingers. Is there a way for the citizens of Kansas to demand an overhaul of the legal system in their state? They need to get some accountability and concern for victim's rights into their courtrooms.

Posted by: Stephanie Location: Manhattan on Jun 14, 2007 at 06:12 AM
Unbelievable!! Judge Dowd is out of touch with reality. To think and say that no permanent damage was suffered by this child, is completely ignorant!!!!! It is so sad to see yet another kansas minor rape victim's rights being put beneath those of the rapist's rights. It's wrong for the victim and the community!!

Posted by: MICHAEL Location: TOPEKA on Jun 5, 2007 at 07:16 PM
ALL SO EASY TO SAY UNTIL YOU OR A LOVED ONE HAS BEEN NOT ONLY VICTIMIZED BY THE CRIMINAL BUT THEN GOES ON TO BE VICTIMIZED BY THE COURT SYSTEM OR AS IN THE CISNEROS CASE BY THE JUDGE. YOU`RE NOT BY CHANCE RELATED TO MATHEW DOWD ARE YOU??????????????????????????????????????

Posted by: Pete Location: Wichita on Jun 4, 2007 at 12:58 PM
Lay people see only the cases which are the exceptions, those exceptions that make the news. Judges have many cases come before them and not all deserve to be locked up. The Court weighs all the facts of the case to arrive at the proper ruling. They also use their experience on the bench to know when a case deserves probation rather than prison. He is your elected official, let him do his job until replaced.

Posted by: Anonymous Location: Topeka on May 31, 2007 at 10:12 PM
This was a heartbreaking story from the beginning,the fact the sex offender is not going to prison is unbelievable. Vote no for Judge Dowd if his name ever appears on a ballot again (for anything).

Posted by: Anonymous Location: topeka on May 29, 2007 at 12:44 PM
my question is how much was the Judge payed to let them off with out doing any time, i have a friend who is doing 5 yrs for stealing something that cost less than $300. why can these men be out where they can do harm to our children and others who just did dumb stuff have to spend so much time away from there children?

Posted by: Anonymous Location: Topeka, KS on May 29, 2007 at 10:56 AM
I am a citizen of this county and I AM OUTRAGED!!!!! I am in total agreement that this Judge needs to be replaced IMMEDIATELY!!! If the juditial system doesnt protect our minor children who will? I mean, this man was convicted by a JURY of 17 counts - not 2 not 5 but 17 counts - and he gets a slap on the hand. Were not talking another minor on minor crime - we are talking a GROWN, KNOWLEDGED adult taking full advantage of a minor CHILD. Might as well given him a key to the local High schools for recess. And what about the depression, anxiety that he has caused upon this minor girl and family. His depression should not even come into play here - he was not proven mentally insane or incompetent. We must stand up for our neighbors and children against judges and crimials such as these!!! THANKS

Posted by: Reava Location: Illinois on May 29, 2007 at 09:36 AM
This sentence is a ridiculous. To say that the 14 year old was not severly traumatized is just to show the judges ignorance on this issue. This victim will be scarred for life. It will never be fully resolved for her. To put her through a trial, have a jury convict the offender, and then have a judge throw it out is unbelievable. I am appalled with our justice system. When will they require judges to go through training on how this type of crime affects our children?

Posted by: Michele Location: aiken, sc on May 29, 2007 at 09:05 AM
This is OUTRAGEOUS!!! PROBATION!!! FREAKING PROBATION!!! To the victim and her family, I am DEEPLY sorry that you are being raped, yet again, by the injustice in this.

Posted by: Tina Location: Topeka on May 28, 2007 at 10:13 PM
This sentencing by the so-called Judge (how does he sleep at night?) did not do any justice by my 14 year old daughter - what did the judge mean, no permanent damage to the victim? She's only 14!! She has her teenage

Posted by: Rose Location: Gardner on May 28, 2007 at 08:07 PM
Unbelievable! This so called judge used being depressed and having study employment as an excuse to give only probation? WHAT? Since when is having depression or having a steady job an excuse to do what ever you want even RAPING a CHILD??? And what is this about the victim having no permanent or severe damage? WHAT? SHE’S 14!!! IS HE CRAZY? I think this judge Dowd needs psychiatric help. We have become a “no fault” society. There should never ever be an excuse for doing such hideous things to a child. This judge should be ashamed of himself! And the guy who did this is SICK! If there’s any rehabilitation to be done, it needs to be behind bars where there is NO chance for this to happen to another girl.

Posted by: Mary Location: Michigan on May 28, 2007 at 05:53 PM
Unbelievable, This guy should not only be doing time he should not be aloud to be anywhere near young girls. I'am truly outraged that the judge could or would not see what will happen to the young girl who will fear going anywhere she may have to run into this disscusting man who preys on young girls.get rid of the judge who puts them back on the streets!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by: Charlene Location: Canton, Michigan on May 28, 2007 at 12:25 AM
This judge is as bad if not worse that the criminals he lets off. He should be in prison with them. Convicts do not like or tolerate people who mess with children.

Posted by: Michael Location: Canton, Michigan on May 28, 2007 at 12:07 AM
The purpose of setting up a sting operation is to catch these predators before they can harm our children. It is the responsibility of an adult, whether it be a parent, a policeman, a judge, a store owner or whomever, the responsibility for the safety and well being our all children rest on the shoulders of adults. To have a judge, an adult who is in the very best position to do something about these predators, allow them to prowl the streets and internet in search of more prey in inadmissable. This judge needs to be replaced and I urge residence of Kansas to assist the families of the victims in doing so.

Posted by: Julie Location: Manhattan on May 27, 2007 at 10:40 PM
This is not okay!!! First off, what message is this telling this survivor? Secondly, what message is this sending to victims that think about coming forward and reporting they too have been sexually assaulted? Also, this gives the disturbing sexual offenders the notion that if they continue to perpetrate, nothing is going to be done about the assaults they commit on someone, let alone a child!!! A CHILD!!! We ought to be a society that protects our children! And with Judge Dowd on the bench allowing 17 felony level convictions to be punished by probation - that's not even a punishment!!!!!!! He has to GO!

Posted by: erin Location: winchester on May 27, 2007 at 09:21 PM
that is so sad,they should be put away.make him pay for what he did.what if that was your daughter?

Posted by: carole Location: california on May 27, 2007 at 04:30 PM
You really need to get in touch with your representatives and governor, this is nonsense. Both cases deserve nothing short of jail time! If they don't go to jail, other young girls become their prey!

Posted by: Bill Location: Topeka on May 27, 2007 at 10:16 AM
BoB is correct on this issue. Judge Dowd has been on the bench for a long time and apparently needs to be replaced. Exercise your rights and replace him. I also thought Kansas had passed Jessicas Law.

Posted by: betty Location: Topeka, Kansas on May 27, 2007 at 09:57 AM
We need to get rid of this judge, right No, he is suppose to protect children, protect the law, why is he in favor someone doing something like that? I we let this go on, what are we telling children? We are telling them we won't Protect them. He needs to spend some time at SRS to see what is going on.

Posted by: carl Location: Coloma MI on May 27, 2007 at 07:55 AM
I should have included my email

Posted by: Jenny Location: Topeka on May 27, 2007 at 07:50 AM
This is unbelievable! Who CAN we trust to protect our children? Obviously not this guy.

Posted by: Jonna Location: Riley on May 27, 2007 at 02:21 AM
It makes you question our great judicial system. I wonder how much he pocketed on this disgusting sentence. Let's see how many rapists and molesters move to this area. Do what you want, a little slap on the wrist and back on the streets to do it again. What a sick and demented judge they have.

Posted by: VICTIMS FATHER Location: TOPEKA on May 27, 2007 at 12:33 AM
THIS MESSAGE GOES OUT TO ALL OUTRAGED MEMBERS OF THIS COMMUNITY. PLEASE STAND WITH OUR FAMILY IN SEEKING THE JUSTICE THAT SHOULD HAVE BEEN SERVED IN THIS CASE AS WELL AS ADVOCATING THE PROMPT REMOVAL, DISBARRMENT, WHATEVER CAN BE DONE TO THIS SO CALLED JUDGE MATHEW DOWD WHO SEEMS TO HAVE QUITE AN AFFECTION FOR THIS TYPE OF CRIMINAL (PEDOPHILE)! THAT PAUL CISNEROS IS AND WAS FOUND TO BE GUILTY OF-17 FELONY COUNTS OF RAPE, SODOMY, IDDEC. LIB.W/ A MINOR AND ON AND ON. FOUND GUILTY BY A JURY OF HIS PEERS THAT LISTENED TO A WEEKS WORTH OF TESTIMONY. DOWDS RESPONSE TO THE PAPER WAS DISGUSTING, I GUESS IF YOU ARE DEPRESSED? HA! AND HAVE HAD A STEADY JOB ITS OK BY HIM TO RAPE YOUNG GIRLS. THIS HAS GOT TO STOP AND HOPEFULLY EVERYONE BEING AS VOCAL AND VIGILANT AS I INTEND TO BE WE CAN ALL MAKE A DIFFERENCE. CALL THE GOVERNOR, LOCAL POLITICIANS, ANYONE AT ALL THAT CAN HELP MAKE THIS NIGHTMARE FOR MY DAUGHTER AND FAMILY GET THE CLOSURE IT DESERVES. OUR CHILDRENS SAFETY AS WELL AS YOUR OWN ARE AT RISK, WE CAN NOT SIT BY AND LET THESE WHARPED, HUG-A -THUG JUDGES ALLOW THESE CRIMMINAL TO ROAM FREELY LOOKING FOR OTHER VULNERABLE PREY. THANKS MICHAEL BURLISON-FATHER OF 14 YEAR OLD RAPE VICTIM

Posted by: rich Location: topeka on May 26, 2007 at 11:55 PM
what a joke the justice system is a slap on the wirst for what he did

Posted by: Charity Location: Kansas on May 26, 2007 at 10:04 PM
To hear that it's now acceptable to rape our young children, I fear greatly for my own daughters. Judge Matthew Dowd needs to be disbarred for violating the justice system in this way.

Posted by: Dreed Location: Topeka on May 26, 2007 at 09:12 PM
Looks like its time for a little street justice.

Posted by: Lia Location: St. George on May 26, 2007 at 06:42 PM
No matter what evidence was presented in this case, the man was CONVICTED of rape and should do time. Perhaps we should keep our children away from Judge Dowd. This is PERVERTED justice.

Posted by: kevin Location: manhattan on May 26, 2007 at 05:42 PM
this sentence NOT right. you can get a dui and go to jail, be a drug dealer and go to prison but when you do something so bad and horrible as this all you get is a slap on the wrist wow way to go court ssystem

Posted by: Tom Location: Topeka Ks. on May 26, 2007 at 05:10 PM
The Judge should be removed from office, no wonder there is alot of sex crimes, they do not get punished

Posted by: Travis Location: Topeka on May 26, 2007 at 03:24 PM
This is extremely hard to believe...it scares me that this judge is on the bench. Not long ago, I believe that he also gave probation to a man for soliciting a minor. Where are his priorities?? Makes one wonder.

Posted by: Christina Location: Valley Falls on May 26, 2007 at 12:03 PM
I believe that he should get a prison sentence why should he be allowed back out on the streets if he raped that little girl. Why should he get away with it.

Posted by: javier matias Location: topeka kansas on May 26, 2007 at 12:02 PM
This guy deserves to go to prison for a long time. This is just another example of how screwed up our justice system is. Especially if this is his second offence. The justice system in this state is one of the most unorganized that I have ever seen. If this had happened in any other state he would be in prison getting raped himself.

Posted by: another concerned citizen Location: topeka on May 26, 2007 at 11:44 AM
how do these judges justify their irresponsible decisions? this is happening all over the U.S.!! what can we do to protect our children if the law won't??

Posted by: BoB Location: Topeka on May 26, 2007 at 11:02 AM
It is geting close to elections, it's up to us whether or not the Judges stay on the bench. I thought Kansas was supposed to be cracking down on sex ofenders, not letting them off easy.

Posted by: Bob Location: topeka on May 26, 2007 at 10:51 AM
I think the judge should be replaced.

Posted by: john Location: usa on May 26, 2007 at 10:08 AM
the laws have to be worded in such a way that incompetent judge have to send monsters like cisneros to jail or Hell as needed. when cisneros does this again dowd should be tried and sent to jail (or Hell) along with cisneros!!!

Posted by: louise Location: topeka on May 26, 2007 at 09:56 AM
how are we supposed to keep our children safe? Dowd should be disbarred.

Posted by: outraged citizen Location: Lawrence on May 26, 2007 at 09:50 AM
Concerned? Anyone that reads this story should be fuming! 2 sickos back on the street to prey on YOUR CHILDREN! To ruin their lives and yours. The persons that are even sicker than these 2 are the judge and the ones that allow him to remain on the bench. SICK!

Posted by: Tim Location: Emporia on May 25, 2007 at 11:56 PM
This judge should be removed and the govenor should waste no time in doing it. No matter what the circumstances anytime a 14 year old is raped the person doing it should be removed from society to prison. This sends a bad message about our judicial system here.

Posted by: Ann Location: Wamego on May 25, 2007 at 11:21 PM
Any adult convicted of sexually assaulting or raping a child should see prison time. This judge should be removed from the bench!

Posted by: no name Location: topeka on May 25, 2007 at 10:39 PM
I can see why the family doesn't accept what the judge gave this idiot it's not right HE SHOULD HAVE GOTTEN PRISON TIME NOW HE IS BACK OUT RUNNING THE STREETS AND U KNOW THAT GIRL WILL BE EMOTIONALLAY SCARD FOR THE REST OF HER LIFE BUT IT SEEMS LIKE THESE PEOPLE THAT MAKE THE LAWS DOESM'T SEEM TO SEE HOW THIS SHIT EFFECTS A PERSONS LIFE

Posted by: concerned citizen Location: Topeka on May 25, 2007 at 10:30 PM
It is unfortunate that our judges are more concerned with being lenient on those members of our community that prey upon the most vulnerable members of our community, rather than actually looking to protect those whom the law has already designated as children who require our protection to the extent that if you harm them, you should incur a prison sentnece.

Feature Links
Brain Foods for Children
View a WebMD article on brain foods for children at the following link:
http://children.webmd.com/child-nutrition-8/brain-foods-for-children
Judicial Evaluations Available Online
Evaluations of Kansas judges up for retention votes in November are available starting Friday, Aug. 29th at the following link:
http://kansasjudicialperformance.org
Summer Blood Drive
Wednesday, August 20, 12:30 pm - 5;30 pm at WIBW Studios 630 SW Commerce Pl. (Map)Click the link to schedule your appointment;and be sure to use the sponsor code WIBW/13. To schedule an appointment by phone, call 785-233-0195. All donors receive a free t-shirt.
http://www.esavealifenow.org
Aug 4, 2008 - Emergency Kenyan Relief
SIM Ministries offering support to Kenya
Aug 1, 2008 - Lyon County Fair
List of fair events
Jul 31, 2008 - 2008 KIDS COUNT Data Book
Ranks states on the well-being of its children
Jul 31, 2008 - Auburn-Washburn Enrollment Schedule
A complete enrollment schedule is available on the USD 437 site.
Jul 29, 2008 - Light the Night - Kansas Chapter
Light the Night raises funds for Leukemia & Lymphoma research
Jul 23, 2008 - Riley County Fair
Riley County Fair 2008: Thursday, July 17- Monday, July 28
Jul 23, 2008 - Shawnee County Fair
2008 Shawnee County Fair: Friday, July 18- Sunday, July 27
Jul 18, 2008 - Sunflower State Games
Check out the games' schedule and how to register! Click the link to visit the Sunflower State Games website.
Jul 15, 2008 - North American Solar Challenge
The 2008 North American Solar Challenge (NASC2008) is a competition to design, build, and drive solar-powered cars in a cross-country time/distance rally event. Teams compete in a 2400 mile drive from Dallas, Texas to Calgary, Alberta.
Jul 14, 2008 - Osage County Fair
The Osage County Fair runs July 13 - 15 in Osage City. Click the link for the schedule of events.
DTV Converter Box Coupons
Information on the digital television conversion, including how to apply for $40 converter box coupons from the federal government, is available at the following link:
http://www.dtv2009.gov
Jul 7, 2008 - Salina Municipal Airport
Great Lakes Airlines at Salina offers enhanced air service between Salina and Denver International Airport, and Salina and Kansas City International Airport beginning July 7, 2008.
Stroke Telemedicine
For more information on strokes and how telemedicine could help in treatment, click the link for the Mayo Clinic
http://www.mayoclinic.org/medical-edge/television.html
Jul 1, 2008 - Big Brothers Big Sisters of Topeka
For more information on volunteering or donating to BBBS of Topeka, call (785) 234-5524 or visit their website.
Jun 30, 2008 - Kansas Department of Labor
Changes for employers who must file online announced by Kansas Department of Labor
UbiDuo Communication Device
For information on the UbiDuo communication device, visit the web site for sComm.
http://www.scommonline.com
Helping Hands Humane Society
For information on how to help Helping Hands Humane Society build a new animal shelter, please visit their web site.
http://www.hhhstopeka.org/